Last week, we had a “surprise” ending where no one went home after the fruit tart pressure test, so we still have ten competitors left in the competition. What challenge will our competitors face this time around?
As the episode starts, we are back in the MasterChef kitchen. Christopher says it’s a tough thing being in the top ten, because he’s missing his seven year anniversary with his girlfriend. Hmm. Do we think it’s time for a family reunion episode? There has to be one every season. And since he’s the first talking head we see this episode, I get the feeling Christopher might be spending a lot more time with his girlfriend soon by being the next one eliminated…
The judges announce that they will be splitting everyone up into teams of five again. Each team will have to make one entree, two sides, and a dessert, all to be served “family style” in one of “America’s best restaurants” (their words, certainly not mine): the MasterChef restaurant. The meal is going to be “very special” because it’s going to be creating “treasured memories” for a family Gordon has invited. It’s one family that they all don’t want to let down. Gee, who could it be? If you saw any of the episode trailers or teasers, you’ll know the answer to that.
Olivia wonders if it could be Gordon’s family, or perhaps previous MasterChef contestants? Tommy wonders if it could be Prince William and Kate Middleton! They will have to wait and see. The judges are going to be deciding on who will be team captains. Captain of the Blue Team will be Derrick, and Captain of the Red Team will be Claudia. Neither has been a team captain before. Derrick says it’s about time for him to be captain and he certainly seems excited about it, as does Claudia.
Derrick gets first pick and goes for Nick. It’s family style and Derrick says they share a similar Italian family background. Claudia’s first pick is someone with “amazing flavor profiles” and a “tenacious attitude”: Katrina. Derrick then picks Olivia, and Claudia picks Hetal. Derrick then chooses Christopher (who said in a talking head that he’d rather be on Claudia’s team.) Claudia then chooses someone who understands vegetables: Stephen.
That leaves Tommy and Shelly as the last to be picked, meaning Derrick will be picking for both teams. Someone who is overlooked a lot is Derrick’s choice: Tommy. So the Blue Team ends up consisting of Derrick, Nick, Olivia, Christopher and Tommy while the Red Team is Claudia, Katrina, Hetal, Stephen and Shelly. Claudia seems to be confident because she knows how to delegate, thanks to her day job as an event planner.
Each team just has 90 minutes to prep and make their full meal. They have a full pantry to work from, and the winning team will be safe from elimination. The losing team will face another challenge and “at least one” of them “may” be sent home. (Let’s hope so after last week!)
Time is called. Claudia is thinking nothing says family style dinner more than roast chicken, maybe with mashed potatoes or potatoes au gratin and broccolini. Hetal suggests strawberry shortcake for dessert and they seem to be set on their plan. Derrick and Nick are thinking Italian for sure. Rack of lamb by Derrick, Caprese salad by Olivia, Nick’s baked ziti, and a chocolate mousse pie. Both teams seem to come to plans quickly and start gathering their ingredients.
The judges discuss the night’s challenge. Christina says this should be exciting because we all learn our love for food first at the family table. Christopher is working in the pie crusts for the Blue Team and seems calm but needs Derrick to give him a little more time to roll them out. Katrina is prepping the chickens but wants Claudia to help truss them.
Gordon goes over to check in with Claudia and hear their menu: herb-roasted whole chicken, garlic mashed potatoes, sauteed broccolini and strawberry shortcake. Gordon is wondering if they’re going to get those whole chickens cooked in time when they will need an hour based on the size of the birds, and they barely have that time left. Stephen thinks they should split the chickens in half in order to reduce the cooking time and he gets Claudia’s approval to do just that.
Christina checks in with Derrick and his Italian family style menu, playing to each of his team members’ strengths. Chris still doesn’t have his pie crusts in the oven which has Derrick anxious, and the judges don’t think the Blue Team’s menu is as cohesive as they would have expected.
Two cheeses on the side dishes? The judges seem to think no one is stepping back to see the big picture. Meanwhile, the Red Team still doesn’t have their half-chickens in the oven with only 45 minutes to go and they are starting to fight over it.
Shelly does not want to be serving anyone “bloody raw chickens” so she makes sure they all get in the oven and thinks Claudia needs to get the team back together. Gordon wants Derrick to think about how it’s going to come together on the table, to have two cheese and tomato side dishes. Olivia suggests instead of the Caprese salad that they do a strawberry and arugula salad instead. Derrick says he has to has to trust her to rework that side, and meanwhile he’s getting annoyed at Christopher and if his pie crusts are going to be okay.
Back on the Red Team, Stephen’s potatoes need a bit more creaminess, which Claudia takes charge of fixing. The chocolate mouse for Blue Team’s pies looks good, and so does Hetal’s strawberry shortcakes. The Blue Team’s ziti looks great, but their chocolate mouse pie once put together? Maybe not so much, by the judges’ estimation.
60 seconds to go and it’s crazy time in the kitchen, all the chefs rushing to get everything out on the table for display. Time is called and Derrick feels the lamb and ziti are cooked perfectly, but he hates their chocolate mousse pie. He’s worried they could go down on dessert. Claudia is hoping that the love the Red Team put into their meal shines through.
And so the chefs have to wait outside while the judges welcome their special “family guests” in the restaurant: the loved ones of the home cooks, of course! Derrick’s mom is there, who didn’t even know he was auditioning for MasterChef. She hasn’t seem him in about a year’s time and the last time he surprised her, so this will be her chance to do the same. Shelly’s daughter is also there, along with Stephen’s son, Stephen Jr. The door opens and the food from both teams is brought in. Each guest will receive an entree and dessert plate from each team. Afterwards, without knowing who was on which team, they will be casting their votes individually for their favorite meal.
We also see that the guests include Nick’s mom, Olivia’s mom, Claudia’s mom, Tommy’s husband, Hetal’s husband, Katrina’s boyfriend, and Christopher’s girlfriend. They are debating if the lamb is under-seasoned on the Blue Team’s plate, and is the ziti misplaced even if it’s really tasty? Claudia’s mom says the chicken is so good. So far Stephen’s son likes the Red Team plate the best. Katrina’s boyfriend? Leaning Blue.
But now for dessert, which Derrick is concerned about. Nick’s mom is leaning toward the strawberry shortcake because she doesn’t think the pie crust is just right, as Derrick feared. Christopher’s girlfriend prefers the Blue Team’s pie as it’s lighter and she liked the bitterness of the dark chocolate. Now that the meal is finished, they will leave either a Blue or Red Team card in the bill fold in front of them, depending on which dinner they liked the best.
The doors open to let in the chefs to finally meet their guests. Of course, the emotional family reunions and waterworks begin…not just for the chefs and their guests but for Graham too, in a sweet moment that shows he’s just a big softie at heart. (Okay, and I defy most of you viewers out there to not get a little emotional yourself.) With each home cook standing behind their seated loved ones, the votes are revealed one by one.
They start with Claudia’s mom, who voted for the Red Team. Shelly’s daughter? Voted Red as well. Roger, Tommy’s husband? Voted Blue. Christopher’s girlfriend voted Blue as well. Hetal’s husband went Red and Olivia’s mom Blue. So three to three, and so far each loved one has voted for their chef’s team.
But Katrina’s boyfriend Alex? Ooops, he’s picked the Blue meal, as he was leaning before. Stephen Jr. went Red. Which means its even again, 4-4, and Nick’s mother goes Red to his disappointment, because of the chicken. That means it’s 5-4 Red-Blue. How did Derrick’s mom vote? She has the deciding vote and she went Red, giving the Red Team the victory, 6-4. That means tomorrow night the Red Team will be facing an elimination challenge, but for tonight they will all get an evening together with their families.
And so we return after a commercial break for the pressure test, and Derrick’s not happy about it. He’s not ready to go home. Good news for him, because one person on his team will be safe and the judges choose him: his lamb dish worked, he was unfortunately let down in the dessert department (what about the fact that his entire menu didn’t really work?)
Graham has a dish to present to them that takes the humble potato and turns it into some thing to be served in the finest restaurants: Gnocchi. Nick is confident seeing this; he says he can make gnocchi in his sleep. They each have one baked potato, eggs, butter, salt, pepper, and sage at their stations, and they have 25 minutes to make a delicious gnocchi dish in a sage brown butter sauce.
The judges talk about the tricks to making good gnocchi; it’s important not to overwork or over-flour the gnocchi and to be sure the baked potato is riced to the proper consistency. While Nick is confident, Olivia has only made gnocchi one time before so she’s anxious. Christopher may have blanched his gnocchi too long, which is worrying the judges.
Nick has his gnocchi dish finished and plated six minutes early! Meanwhile, Tommy’s gnocchi is “exploding” so he redoes all of his gnocchi from the extra dough he’d made. With less than three minutes to go, will he be able to complete them in time?
90 seconds left and Tommy’s got to plate. But he’s poured all the brown butter over his gnocchi! Will that be his doom? Nick is first up with his classic potato gnocchi topped with fried sage leaves. The plate smells incredible, Gordon says. “Wow,” crispy, light, seasoned beautifully. He’s nailed it, it seems, and Christina agrees. So light, so pillowy. She just wishes they were a little bit bigger.
Olivia is next with her gnocchi. She was a bit of an “underdog” in this elimination test given her inexperience with making them, but Graham says visually hers are the most beautiful. Not a lot he would change. Delicious, even better than Nick’s, according to Gordon.
Third up for tasting is Christopher. Christina is disappointed by the presentation. The dumplings are on the under-seasoned side and the filling tastes a little dry. With “at least” one person going home, Christina says it’s probably going to be between him and Tommy (why should she say that before she’s even tasted Tommy’s gnocchi?!) Gordon wants to know why his plate looks like it’s suffered from an ant infestation, Christopher says it’s cracked pepper, so that the diner can add how much seasoning they want—a choice Gordon doesn’t think is a good one. Gordon goes in for a taste and Christina calls out Christopher for rolling his eyes up at the balcony while Gordon does so. She’s ready to open the door and send Christopher out right now for being “disrespectful”. It’s a painfully awkward confrontation; we’ve known for weeks now that Christina doesn’t like Christopher, does it have to always be so obvious? This seems like another set-up to send someone home for attitude more than their dish, just like with Sara a few episodes before. Gordon says the big issue with the gnocchi is that it needs more seasoning.
Tommy is last for tasting, and his gnocchi is practically swimming in a pool of browned butter. Why so much? Tommy says it’s “the Jackson Pollack in” him that can’t hold back, but Gordon calls it “Jackson Bollocks”. But, the weird thing is they actually taste decent. Gordon doesn’t get it. Graham says the flavor is on the money, even if the presentation is not there like it is with Christopher’s.
It seems pretty clear that Olivia and Nick did well and will be safe, and that’s what Christina confirms after the judges “consult”. That leaves Christopher and Tommy up for elimination as expected. Christopher? It wasn’t one of his strongest performances, because the flavor was missing. Tommy restarted his gnocchi as time was running out, but then “destroyed” his dish at the last second with all of that brown butter. Gordon tells Tommy he needs to say goodbye to Christopher…and head upstairs to the balcony. It’s not even a very convincing fake out decision! The judges say that Christopher is heading home because he didn’t taste his gnocchi mix and that’s a mistake that can’t be made at this point in the competition.
So, what of this episode overall? I thought it was enjoyable seeing the competitors family members and loved ones like this; it was a little more personal than in the past when we’ve seen letters from home or just a few loved ones up in the balcony without a lot of interaction with the competitors. And it was fun seeing them be the judges of the food, too—probably trying to figure out who was on which team based on the food and in some cases not getting it right! But beyond that, the elimination test was a bit predictable in outcome. Christopher’s departure from the competition was overdue; I don’t think he deserved to be in the top 10 compared to some who were eliminated earlier like Sara who seemed much better cooks overall.
But I was annoyed by the clear example of inconsistency in the judging. What really matters more: taste or appearance? Some weeks ago, Charlie was sent home in the birthday cake pressure test because his cake looked terrible, even though it tasted really good. Here, Tommy was safe because his gnocchi tasted decent but his plating/presentation was the worst and he did seem to have technical errors that Christopher didn’t. That doesn’t make sense, unless you just accept that eliminations really have very little to do with what gets served to the judges and only comes down to who they want to keep safe for another week’s entertainment value, and who’s 15 minutes of fame is over.
Whose time will be up next week? Do you have any guesses at this point? From the previews all I can see is that we’re going for “Southern Flare” and everyone has to flambe a dish for the Mystery Box challenge. Tommy should be in his element with this challenge, so it’s hard to say even though I wonder if it’s finally going to be time for him to say goodbye after this week’s close call.
Want to share your thoughts on this season of MasterChef and learn more about the competitors? Then check out my MasterChef Season 6 fan page on Wizzley!
Related posts at Spacial Anomaly
sockii is just your typical Jane-of-All-Trades who never has enough time in her day for all of her projects. She has written for many websites online including Squidoo, Zujava, Yahoo! Contributors Network, HubPages and Wizzley. She has been attending and vending at science fiction and media conventions for over 15 years, and for several years ran an art gallery and jewelry store in Philadelphia. Today she is happy to be living in South Jersey with her partner David and their 6 cats. Sockii is a member of several affiliate sales programs including Amazon Associates and Viglink. Products from these services may be advertised on her posts and pages to generate sales commissions.